Answers.Founder questions, by Humble

How do I pre-sell a product before I build it?

Put a one-page offer with a price and a start date in front of five people who have the problem, and ask them to pay. Here's how to run it and read the results.

3 min read · Updated 18 Nov 2026

The short answer

Write the offer on one page with a price and a start date, show it to five people who have the problem, and ask how they'd like to pay. Ask for full payment or a deposit, and promise a refund if you don't deliver by the date. Buffer's founder ran a lighter version first: a pricing page for a product that didn't exist yet.

In 2010, Joel Gascoigne tested Buffer with two web pages and no product. The first page explained the idea and asked for an email address. Once people were signing up, he added a pricing page with plans in between, so visitors had to choose a plan before they reached the email form (Buffer).

A small number clicked on paid plans. That was enough for him to build a basic version over about seven weeks of evenings and weekends. Buffer launched on 30 November and had its first paying customer within four days.

A click on a price is the lightest kind of pre-sale, and the table below runs all the way up to full payment.

How much commitment to ask for

Every pre-sale asks someone to give something up before the product exists. The more they give up, the more weight you can put on their answer.

What they doWhat it tells you
Click a plan on a pricing pageThey’re curious about paying
Leave an email after seeing the priceThe price didn’t put them off
Agree a price and a start date in writingThey expect to buy, and they’ve said when
Pay a depositThey’ll put money down to hold a place
Pay in full, upfrontThey want it enough to take a chance on you

Aim as far down this table as your offer allows. A service you deliver yourself can usually ask for the first month in full. A product that takes months to make might ask for a deposit.

How to run one this week

  1. Write the offer on one page. Who it’s for, what they get, the price and the date it starts.
  2. Pick five people who have the problem. If you’ve filled in a First-Customer Card, start with the names on it.
  3. Show them the offer and say the price. Then ask how they’d like to pay. Their answer to that tells you more than whether they like the idea.
  4. Make it safe to say yes. Give a start date and promise a full refund if you don’t deliver by then.
  5. Write down every response. Keep their words, and note the result: paid, deposit, later or no.

Reading the results

Five conversations is a small sample, so read it for direction.

What happenedWhat it suggests
Two or more paid or left a depositKeep going, and start delivering by hand
Several said “later” and gave a reasonAsk what would have to change. It’s often timing or price
Everyone liked it and nobody paidThe problem may not cost them enough yet, or the offer doesn’t show what it saves
Nobody wanted to talk about itCheck you’re talking to people who have the problem before you change the offer

The same idea at a larger size

Pre-sales can fund a whole first batch. In April 2012, Pebble asked Kickstarter backers for $100,000 to make a smartwatch. It hit that goal within two hours, and by the time funding closed on 18 May, 68,929 backers had pledged $10,266,845 (Wikipedia)). The company had struggled to attract traditional investors after it took the Pebble name.

Your first offer will probably be far smaller. It works the same way: the money arrives before the product does.

Keep it fair

Taking money for something that doesn’t exist yet puts the responsibility on you. Sell only what you can deliver by the date you give, keep a record of who paid what, and if you miss the date, give the money back without being asked.

Gascoigne’s lesson from the build was that the first version should be far smaller than you expect. His advice for the moment the early signal arrives is quoted below.

When the signal is there that the product is good enough, shout about it!
Joel Gascoigne, co-founder of Buffer (February 2011)

In Humble’s 30 days, the offer takes shape in week one and the first asks for money happen in week two. The minimum version gets built in week three, for the people who have already said yes.

The Humble Edge · Sunday email

Get one of these every Sunday.

One founder problem and one thing to do before Monday.

Questions

How is a pre-sale different from a waitlist?

Joining a waitlist costs nothing, so it tells you about curiosity. A pre-sale asks for money or a firm commitment, which tells you whether the problem is worth paying to fix. Our piece on waitlists covers what they can and can't show.

How big should a deposit be?

Big enough that someone thinks before paying it. For a service you deliver yourself, asking for the first month in full is often simpler than a deposit.

What if nobody pays?

Look at who you asked and what they said. If the people with the problem badly all said no, ask what would have to change. It's often the price, the timing or how clearly the offer shows what it saves.

Do I need a website to pre-sell?

A one-page document, an email or a conversation is enough. Take payment with an invoice or a payment link, and keep a record of who paid and what you promised.

Should I offer a discount for paying early?

A small one is fine. Our piece on pricing with no customers covers why early discounts are best kept small.

Try something

While you're here

Next step

Is your idea worth 30 days? Find out free.

Five questions about your idea and a straight answer. It's week zero of Humble's 30 days, and it costs nothing.

More in validate